The Human Value of Public Libraries in the Age of AI
New research from library staff across the UK and Ireland reveals what AI can’t replace.
The speed and reach of AI development is causing society to experience a cultural shift. It’s changing how people search for information, get answers and make decisions. As AI tools become part of daily life, it’s causing public libraries to reflect on how their role could be impacted.
Over a 6-week period, Lorensbergs collected nearly 80 responses from library staff at a series of public library conferences, from library assistants to heads of service. We asked one question: In an age of AI, what is the human value of using a public library? Here’s a summary of what the answers revealed, with a full report available to download from here.
Connection comes first – 46%
Almost half of respondents pointed first to human connection. For many, the library is a valued place where they can rely on having a conversation with another person:Combating loneliness, social interaction and communication between people to boost health and wellbeing – Library Service Coordinator, Wales
Empathy. Conversations when the customer may live alone and a library staff member may be the only human conversation in a day or week – Librarian, Northern England
AI can answer a question. It cannot be a building, a familiar face, or offer an experiential dimension to spending time, finding support or participating in activities:The ability to see the physical reference material, to use computers to look up knowledge, to speak to a physical being – Library Operations Manager, Midlands, England
In summary, the attraction of being physically present to use services, resources and events, in what is seen as a social setting, cannot be underestimated.
Trust in an age of uncertainty – 24%
A quarter of respondents named trust directly, often in contrast to AI’s known accuracy problems. Several raised concerns about misinformation and unreliable AI answers, presented as facts.
Reliable and trustworthy verified information – Librarian, Ireland
Having accurate helpful responses for humans instead of weird AI hallucination answers to your questions – Systems Librarian, Ireland
A prison librarian in Scotland raised a further point about trust and integrity:
Humans understand copyright laws and generally agree to follow them – Prison Librarian, Scotland
A strategic manager in Wales summed up what’s on offer:
Libraries offer guided support, human judgement, and ethical stewardship of information in ways algorithms cannot – places where people can learn, belong, and think freely together without being treated as data or customers – Strategic Manager, Wales
Professional judgement, not just information – 18%
AI can generate an answer to almost anything. What it struggles to do is tell you which answer is right for you. As one head of libraries in England put it, borrowing a well-known line:Google can bring you back 100,000 answers. A librarian can bring you back the right one – Head of Libraries, Northern England
A library assistant in Ireland went further, connecting curation to critical thinking itself:
The value of having a variety of contradictory reading material in one place to teach us to think critically and evaluate different sources. This skill is so important with the increasing pressure of AI – Library Assistant, Ireland
Another respondent linked professionalism and good judgement to safety:
AI isn’t going to ensure that it’s giving safe, appropriate information to vulnerable people – Engagement and partnerships manager, London
Bridging the digital divide
Not everyone has equal access to AI. For some people, the library is the only way in – both to the internet and to supported AI use:
The gateway for the digitally excluded to be able to assess and embrace AI, thus performing a crucial community and social role – Library and Archives Services Manager, London
A further respondent focused on the safety aspect of using AI and the support that libraries provide to users with lower digital skills:
Being able to come into the library to access the tech to have a staff member show them how to get online and how to safely explore AI – Library Manager, London
A level-headed response
Despite the fast pace of AI’s rise, library staff are responding with composure. Many see AI as simply the latest tool to take in their stride, and are able to help users take an informed and positive approach to using it.
AI is just another tool to learn and use – good if you embrace it – City Librarian, Ireland
AI is just a tool that can assist human intrigue. Libraries don’t need to change, just regard and support through the change – Development Manager, London
Conclusion
Library staff are responding to genuinely new challenges – a wave of disinformation and deep fakes, a digital divide that risks leaving some people unable to access AI at all, and a public that increasingly needs help telling accurate facts from AI-generated misinformation. Meanwhile, what they offer is well practised: trust, judgement, and an environment supporting essential human contact. AI has not created the need for these things – it has simply made their absence in people’s lives more starkly visible.
Technology will at some point fail or simply not have the answer. This research shows that trained, trusted professionals are always ready to help. Moreover, they are well placed to support society navigate through the opportunities that AI presents, bringing balance and good judgement along the way.
That is not a nostalgic view of the public library. On the evidence presented, it is a fair description of its value today, and in the years to come.
Discover More








